« “Slow Parenting” | Main | On “Cheap Toys” »

June 23, 2011



Somebody still has to create new games for this mystery company to sell, no?

True, it's tough to compete with the big guys, but the big guys are also slow to respond and don't necessarily innovate like those little scrappy game companies/independent inventors that are pretty much everywhere(go take a look at all the game projects on www.Kickstarter.com).

Potentially, a company with a great brand, but no actual product, could take advantage of the fact that there are lots of indie inventors and small game companies looking for a good place to sell their products. This model impacts the traditional game company and also the game/toy retailer, but it also provides a new venue for these game companies to sell their products...and it raises awareness of new products which one could argue winds up having a positive impact on the local retailers...

Thanks for the thought provoking post!
Andrew Innes


It seems obvious to me that digital marketing can solve the diminishing funnel problem, at least. Develop a board game, develop a digital demo version of the game, distribute the first through an online retailer like Amazon and spread the second as far and wide as possible through every channel you can think of, for free.


Who's the "mystery company" that can sell 10,000 units of a game "easily" and has a great brand with loyal followers. Really? Or, is that made up?

Brian Maggio

Note from Brian:
We are under a Nondisclosure with the company mentioned in this post, so will "protect the names of the innocent". However, the company is in fact very real, and owned by one of the most successful publishers around the globe. The purpose of the blog was not to raise controversy, but rather to illustrate the point that "Traditional" game companies will most likely have to adapt to a whole new competitive set in order to survive. No fiction here.

Kerri Neubek

Although I'm fairly new to this industry - this makes a lot of sense. Wish I had a crystal ball, now, that's a toy that would sell anywhere!
Thanks for the article Brian.

Kerri Neubek
Games for Dames

Tom Lennett

I am a UK based Independent games manufacturer and I am totally aware of my limitations versus my aspirations.

I have tried to get in with the incumbents, as you call them, to no avail. Letters, emails, phone calls, they are all unanswered, as though I never existed to them.

I have approached the independent toy retailers and their views are all the same; “Who are you? We have never heard of your board game. Why would I give valuable shelf space to something with no track record?” As a onetime retailer myself I cannot blame them.

Retailers are in between a rock and a hard place, I fully sympathise with them but as you say families still want board games; so what does the Independent do? He finds another route to his customers and that could be setting up his own online shop, doing deals with other online stores and using the likes of Facebook, Amazon, and E-Bay, put simply, the Internet.

I am happy to grow slowly, as I am presently doing , and not fall into the very appealing but deadly “overtrading” trap.

As usual a thought provoking read, thanks.

Tom Lennett
It’s the player that counts.

David E. Whitcher

"Hire a designer, developer, warehouse, and an admin, and you’re already in for $200 - $300k before selling one unit."

I am a freelance game designer. Most publishers license work from people like me because paying a royalty on something I developed on my own time is much more cost effective than paying someone an hourly fee to develop a game that might only sell 3-5K copies. The other upside is you don’t need to pay anything upfront unless I’m charging a fee, which is relatively small, so you can retain the rights while it’s in development.

I also do custom development for those that need something specific but I and most freelance designers have several products to offer at any given time. As a publisher you can contact the designer for a list of games and then review and test the ones you are interested in which cost you very little.

Steve Hart

Hey Brian,
Great article! I know it's been awhile since you posted this but I just now came across it. I think you're definitely onto something. Can you tell me, in the article above are you refering to this company selling digital games or analog (physical) games? Thanks. Hope to run into sometime soon.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

TWM_Home of the friday blog_200x400